Saturday, March 11, 2006

Pressure Profilin'

I drove down to Gimme Coffee today to test out my newest piece of geeked out gear: a Programmable Pressure Profiling Pump. This is a homemade gadget designed to replace the rotary or vibe pump in an espresso machine. In theory, it will allow the barista artist to "sculpt" the water pressure profile through both the initial "preinfusion" phase and the main "extraction" phase.

I was inspired to build this thing by many people. Among them is John Bicht at Versalab, whose M3x machine reportedly has full pressure profiling capability through a computer interface. John says that changes in extraction pressure of only 0.03 bar (!) are tastable on his machine. Then there's Jim Schulman, whose experiments with pump machines and levers have led to some fascinating insights on pressure profiling. And Sean Lennon, home barista and industrial robot designer extraordinaire, has generously coached me on many key engineering details.

With technical help from Tomas (Gimme's excellent macchinesti), and moral support from Kevin and John Gant, we got the contraption hooked up to a venerable La Marzocco GS2. That's Tomas working on the machine in the photo.

So how was the coffee? Well, at first it sucked big time. But with Kevin acting as head barista, we gradually tweaked, tasted, sipped, spat and tweaked some more. We raised the preinfusion pressure, we increased the preinfusion time, we raised the extraction pressure. By the end, the coffee was coming out pretty damn nice -- and Kevin was really late for dinner!

It's a little overwhelming working with pressure profiles. There are so many combinations of things to try. But I believe that with proper attention to barista technique, grind quality, water composition, brew temperature, machine cleanliness, and now pressure profile, we are freeing ourselves from the tyranny of mechanical limitations. The aim, of course, is not to remain obsessed with the espresso machine itself, but to have unfettered control of the espresso process. Then we can finally extract our best from any given blend or roast with unprecedented artistry.

So what exactly is this Profiling Pump? Well, in its present incarnation it's a combination of pistons, valves, sensors and electronics that I won't attempt to explain (but that's part of it to the right of the grinder in the photo). It'll be installed on the GS2 at the SCAA Gimme Coffee booth in Charlotte, so please come by, say hello, and check it out. We'll be right near the BGA booth, so you won't have to go far.

At the end of the afternoon we had plenty of coffee heaped up below our grinder. Jay's famous BGA ad in Barista Magazine (which showed a grinder heaped with ground coffee) had nothing on us! We tried not to waste, honest! :-)

6 comments:

  1. See Andy, you need a black Mazzer. Doesn't show up nearly as much mess ;)

    Re the rest of the article. The gears are always spinning Andy, which is why we love you. Are you going to usurp the lever / spring lever / rotary pump / vibe pump world and bring a fifth technology to the table? Woot.

    ReplyDelete
  2. > you need a black Mazzer. Doesn't show up nearly as much mess ;)

    Hey Mark, they offer grinders in various colors, including black, but a BROWN grinder would be best. On the selection list, they could call the color "ESPRESSO." :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'll nominate Andy for this week's "gifted and talented" award. He must have aced his tests in Industrial Arts class. After 3 hours of geeksquading, what were the observations?

    Well, picture a PID connected to an acute pressure sensor. You usually pull shots at 9 bar? Now you can pull shots at 8.59 bar, or 9.12. You want to make sure all 21 grams in your pf basket are fully wetted and swelled before a steady increase to full extraction pressure? How much pressure do you want to preinfuse at and how long do you want it to last to last?

    As I recall, our best results were at 4 bar of preinfusion for 8(?) seconds before ramping up to 9, showing first drops around 11 seconds. The crema seemed to me to be more refined: more uniform bubble size? Smaller bubbles? I was noticing above-average viscosity and mouthfeel, maybe even an "after-mouthfeel" if there can be such a thing. The mottling, the clarity of contrast between light and dark colors on the top of the crema, was getting ridiculous. The last 3 shots (using our French Roast as a southern Italian blend) gave a rousing perfumey nose, big caramel sweetness, and NO insubordinate flavors in the cup.

    The exercise left me convinced that evaluating espresso parameters and results is like a mansion full of funhouse mirrors. More mystery & abberration behind every door. Quit after 3 hours or plan to be sick.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Brilliant. I will start my list of questions. I hope you are keeping a log and it is available to see in Charlotte. See you there.

    -Isaac

    ReplyDelete
  5. If "Alton Brown" was a verb, you'd be doing it.

    ReplyDelete